Review · secondary evidenceProgress Report

Surface-Mounted Metal-Organic Frameworks: Crystalline and Porous Molecular Assemblies for Fundamental Insights and Advanced Applications

Lars Heinke and Christof Woll · Advanced Materials · 2019

This dossier represents secondary evidence: section summaries, claims and benchmarks are paraphrased for this database, not quoted. Check quantitative values against the linked primary study, and cite the review itself (10.1002/adma.201806324) for its arguments.

11review sections
7material families
17review claims
14secondary benchmarks
30cited studies
8research gaps

Review scope

Reviews surface-mounted metal-organic frameworks as oriented crystalline thin-film model systems for diffusion, charge transport, defects, photoswitchable coatings, membranes and crystalline chromophore assemblies.

Coverage
1994–2019
Category
Core Thin Film Device
Material scope
Surface-mounted metal-organic frameworks grown by layer-by-layer liquid-phase epitaxy · HKUST-1 and related Cu paddle-wheel SURMOFs · Guest-loaded SURMOFs including TCNQ, ferrocene and azobenzene-functionalised films · SURMOF heteromultilayers and crystalline chromophore assemblies
Transport scope
Electronic charge hopping, incoherent tunnelling and molecular superexchange · Guest diffusion, surface barriers and QCM uptake measurements · Proton conduction in guest-loaded photoswitchable SURMOFs · Exciton and triplet-transfer transport across organic-organic heterojunctions
Application scope
Thin-film optical and electronic devices · Remote-controlled molecular release · Photoswitchable gas-separation membranes · Ion-conducting and chromophore-assembly model systems
Explicit exclusions
Exhaustive primary synthesis recipes · Complete MOF powder literature · Full primary extraction of all photophysical or membrane data
Source
1 · Abstract
Evidence role
Context, taxonomy and secondary benchmarking

Section map

The review’s argument is preserved as a navigable set of section summaries.

6.4. SURMOFs as Regular Model System for Isolated Azobenzene Moieties

8-10

Treats large-pore SURMOFs as model matrices for isolated azobenzene side groups, enabling IR-derived thermal relaxation kinetics and activation-energy comparison with quantum-chemical calculations.

Relevance: Supporting · 9 · 6.4. SURMOFs as Regular Model System · Figure 8

4. Determining Electrical Conductivity

3-4

Positions SURMOFs as better electrical test structures than powders, then reviews HKUST-1 conductivity modulation by electroactive guests and the need to distinguish hopping, tunnelling, band and superexchange models.

Relevance: Core · 4 · 4. Determining Electrical Conductivity · Figure 3

3. MOF Thin Films with Very Low Defect Density

2-3

Reviews why high-quality SURMOFs are better suited than MOF powders for optical and XPS characterisation, and how spectroscopy, synthesis optimisation and modulation quantify or reduce defects.

Relevance: Core · 3 · 3. MOF Thin Films with Very Low Defect Density · Figure 2

5. Unique Model System for Diffusion Experiments

4-5

Explains the value of thin, QCM-integrated SURMOFs for measuring slow guest diffusion, uptake amount, activation energy and mixture uptake where large crystals or conventional methods are limiting.

Relevance: Core · 5 · 5. Unique Model System for Diffusion Experiments · Figure 4

7-8. Excitation Transfer and Chromophore Assemblies

10

Reviews SURMOF heterojunctions and crystalline chromophore assemblies as structurally defined systems for triplet transfer, photon upconversion and directional exciton diffusion.

Relevance: Core · 10 · 7-8 · Figure 9

1. Introduction

1-2

Defines MOFs and SURMOFs, contrasts layer-by-layer film growth with solvothermal powder synthesis, and frames oriented thin films as model systems for optical, electrical and interfacial transport studies.

Relevance: Core · 2 · Introduction · Figure 1

2. MOF Mechanical Properties

2

Summarises HKUST-1 SURMOF elastic and thermal-expansion measurements, emphasising agreement between experiment and computation and stability during heating/cooling cycles.

Relevance: Supporting · 2 · 2. MOF Mechanical Properties

6. Photoswitchable Nanoporous Coating

6-7

Frames azobenzene-functionalised SURMOFs as crystalline, porous alternatives to amorphous photoswitchable polymers, enabling conformational switching with sufficient free volume and quantitative comparison.

Relevance: Core · 7 · 6. Photoswitchable Nanoporous Coating · Figure 6

6.1-6.3. Photoswitchable Release, Membranes and Proton Conduction

8-9

Reviews remote guest release, dynamically tunable H2/CO2 membrane selectivity and light-controlled proton conduction using azobenzene or fluorinated azobenzene SURMOFs.

Relevance: Core · 8 · 6.1-6.3 · Figures 6-7

9. Summary

11

Concludes that oriented crystalline SURMOFs are useful model systems for diffusion, defects, electrical conduction, photoswitchable function and anisotropic triplet-exciton transport.

Relevance: Core · 11 · 9. Summary

5.1. The Surface Barrier Phenomenon

5-6

Uses SURMOF thickness-dependent cyclohexane uptake to separate diffusion-limited behaviour from surface-barrier-limited uptake, linking barriers to near-surface defects caused by water exposure.

Relevance: Core · 6 · 5.1. The Surface Barrier Phenomenon · Figure 5

Taxonomies

Classification systems are attributed to this review and are not treated as a global material registry.

Mechanistic Interpretation Of MOF Conductivity

Electrical transport model classes

The conductivity section uses these model classes to interpret guest-loaded HKUST-1 SURMOF data and distinguish ferrocene and TCNQ behaviour.

Categories: band-like transport · incoherent tunnelling · simple hopping · extended hopping or molecular superexchange

4 · 4. Determining Electrical Conductivity

Film Growth Implementation

Layer-by-layer SURMOF deposition modes

Different layer-by-layer methods are presented as routes to oriented SURMOFs, with surface rinsing and ultrasonication affecting morphology and optical quality.

Categories: dip coating · spray coating · spin coating · robotic dipping with ultrasonication

2 · Introduction · Figure 1

Thickness Dependence Of Uptake TimeAuthor-proposed

Diffusion-limited versus surface-barrier-limited uptake

Thickness-dependent QCM uptake in SURMOFs is used to distinguish intrinsic diffusion through pores from external surface resistance caused by blocked pore entrances.

Categories: quadratic thickness dependence for diffusion-controlled uptake · linear thickness dependence for surface-barrier influence

6 · 5.1. The Surface Barrier Phenomenon · Figure 5

Placement Of Photoresponsive MoleculesAuthor-proposed

Photoswitch incorporation modes

The review separates structural incorporation of azobenzene units into MOF linkers from guest-like embedding in pores, then highlights fluorinated switches as a route to avoid UV light.

Categories: photoswitches as dangling side groups on linkers · light-responsive molecules embedded in pores · fluorinated azobenzene switches for visible-light operation

7 · 6. Photoswitchable Nanoporous Coating

Phenomenon Studied Using Oriented Crystalline FilmsAuthor-proposed

SURMOF model-system functions

Across the progress report, SURMOFs are organised by the fundamental process they make measurable in a structurally defined thin-film geometry.

Categories: defect quantification · charge transport · mass diffusion · photoisomerisation · exciton transfer

11 · 9. Summary

Physical Form And Measurement SuitabilityAuthor-proposed

SURMOF thin films versus MOF powders

The review repeatedly contrasts high-quality oriented films with powders or large crystals, arguing that films reduce optical scattering, simplify electrical contacts and shorten diffusion times.

Categories: oriented thin SURMOF films · particulate solvothermal MOF powders · large single crystals

3 · 3. MOF Thin Films with Very Low Defect Density

Material families

Review-defined families retain their representative materials and conduction descriptions.

Azobenzene-functionalised SURMOFs

Porous Crystalline Thin Films And Membranes

SURMOF films with azobenzene units incorporated into linkers or side groups, enabling light-triggered conformational changes and tunable guest interactions.

Conduction: Guest proton conduction can be reduced or increased by light-controlled trans-cis switching of azo side groups.

Representative materials: Cu2(AzoBPDC)2(BiPy) · Cu2(AzoBPDC)2(AzoBiPyB) · Cu2(F2AzoBDC)2(dabco)

Nodes / linkers: Cu paddle-wheel units · AzoBPDC · AzoBiPyB · F2AzoBDC · BiPy · dabco

8 · 6.1-6.3 · Figures 6-7

Crystalline chromophore assembly SURMOFs

Ordered Crystalline Thin-Film Chromophore Arrays

SURMOF-based ordered chromophore arrays used to study aggregate photophysics, anisotropic energy transport and exciton diffusion.

Conduction: Electronic excitation rather than ground-state charge transport; triplet and exciton transport are controlled by interface and packing.

Representative materials: anthracene-based CCA SURMOFs · H-aggregate SURMOFs · Pd-DCP/ADB upconversion heterojunctions

Nodes / linkers: MOF nodes not exhaustively specified · anthracene linkers · porphyrin linkers · chromophore-based carboxylate linkers

10 · 8. SURMOFs as Model-Systems

Cu2(ndc)2(dabco) SURMOFs

Three-Dimensional Porous Thin Film

Pillared Cu-based SURMOF films used as a QCM diffusion model system for ferrocene uptake and activation-energy extraction.

Conduction: Discussed for ferrocene diffusion rather than film conductivity.

Representative materials: Cu2(ndc)2(dabco) SURMOF

Nodes / linkers: Cu paddle-wheel units · ndc · dabco pillars

5 · 5. Unique Model System for Diffusion Experiments

Electroactive guest-loaded HKUST-1 SURMOFs

Guest-Loaded Porous Thin Film

HKUST-1 thin films loaded with redox-active guests to alter electrical conductivity and test charge-transport mechanisms.

Conduction: Ferrocene loading is interpreted by incoherent tunnelling or charge hopping; TCNQ-loaded films require extended hopping or molecular superexchange.

Representative materials: TCNQ-loaded HKUST-1 SURMOF · ferrocene-loaded HKUST-1 SURMOF

Nodes / linkers: Cu paddle-wheel dimers · benzene tricarboxylate

4 · 4. Determining Electrical Conductivity · Figure 3

HKUST-1 SURMOFs

Three-Dimensional Porous Framework Grown As Oriented Thin Film

Oriented Cu paddle-wheel MOF thin films used as reference systems for mechanical properties, defect quantification, diffusion and guest-modulated conductivity.

Conduction: Pristine material behaves as a large-bandgap insulator; conductivity can be increased by electroactive guests such as TCNQ or ferrocene.

Representative materials: HKUST-1 SURMOF · Cu3(BTC)2-type SURMOF

Nodes / linkers: Cu paddle-wheel dimers · benzene tricarboxylate

3 · 3. MOF Thin Films with Very Low Defect Density · Figure 1

SURMOF heteromultilayers

Multilayer Crystalline Thin-Film Heterostructure

Layer-by-layer stacks of two MOF structures with similar lattice parameters but distinct linkers or properties, producing defined organic-organic heterointerfaces.

Conduction: Used for transport across interfaces, including guest release gating and triplet exciton transfer.

Representative materials: Cu2(BPDC)2(BiPy)/Cu2(AzoBPDC)2(BiPy) · Pd-DCP/ADB SURMOF heterojunctions

Nodes / linkers: Cu paddle-wheel units · Pd porphyrin-containing sensitiser units · BPDC · AzoBPDC · BiPy · Pd-DCP · ADB

2 · Introduction · Figure 1

UHM-3 Cu-dimer SURMOFs

Porous Crystalline Thin Film

A different Cu++ dimer MOF thin-film family used to compare defect concentrations and temperature-induced defect formation.

Conduction: Discussed for defect chemistry rather than electronic conduction.

Representative materials: UHM-3 SURMOF

Nodes / linkers: Cu++ dimers · not specified in review text

3 · 3. MOF Thin Films with Very Low Defect Density · Figure 2a

Synthesis strategies

Review-level synthesis principles remain separate from primary-study recipes.

Defect control by modulators and optimised parameters

Growth conditions, water modulation and broader optimisation are described as ways to tune SURMOF defect density.

Claimed effects: Defect density can be characterised and varied, enabling systematic links between defects and optical or transport properties.

Controlling variables: water modulator · growth parameters · rinsing quality · thermal exposure

Representative materials: HKUST-1 SURMOF · UHM-3 SURMOF

Caveat: Some defect formation is linked to water exposure; defect control can be material- and surface-specific.

3 · 3. MOF Thin Films with Very Low Defect Density

Exchange of linker or metal solutions during growth

Changing the organic linker and/or metal-node solution during LbL synthesis allows a second SURMOF structure to be grown on top of the first.

Claimed effects: Produces structurally defined heteromultilayers for studying optical excitation, charge transfer and gated guest transport at internal interfaces.

Controlling variables: linker exchange · metal-node exchange · lattice matching · layer sequence

Representative materials: Pd-DCP/ADB SURMOF heterojunction · Cu2(BPDC)2(BiPy)/Cu2(AzoBPDC)2(BiPy)

Caveat: Requires compatible structures and linker lengths to maintain oriented epitaxial growth.

3 · Introduction · Figure 1

Layer-by-layer liquid-phase epitaxy

Functionalised substrates are alternately exposed to separate metal-node and organic-linker solutions, producing oriented crystalline SURMOF films rather than bulk powders.

Claimed effects: Enables highly oriented, monolithic MOF thin films with well-defined electrical contacts and optical quality.

Controlling variables: substrate functionalisation · metal-source solution · organic-linker solution · number of exposure cycles

Representative materials: HKUST-1 SURMOF

Caveat: The review points to other literature for detailed synthesis recipes; extraction should not treat this as a full protocol.

3 · Introduction · Figure 1

SURMOF deposition on mesoporous membrane supports

Photoswitchable SURMOFs are deposited on mesoporous supports and irradiated in situ during membrane-separation measurements.

Claimed effects: Allows reversible and continuous tuning of H2/CO2 separation factors by light-controlled azobenzene isomerisation.

Controlling variables: support porosity · cis-azobenzene fraction · UV or blue illumination · gas feed composition

Representative materials: Cu2(AzoBPDC)2(AzoBiPyB) SURMOF membrane

Caveat: The review presents this as a specialised membrane demonstration rather than general proof for all MOF membranes.

8 · 6.2. Dynamic Remote-Control · Figure 6c-e

Azobenzene linker and side-group design

Azobenzene units are incorporated as dangling side groups or into pillared-layer linkers with enough free volume for trans-cis isomerisation.

Claimed effects: Provides light-switchable permeability, adsorption, proton conduction and molecular model systems in crystalline porous films.

Controlling variables: azobenzene linker length · free space in pores · side-group density · fluorination

Representative materials: Cu2(AzoBPDC)2(BiPy) · Cu2(AzoBPDC)2(AzoBiPyB) · Cu2(F2AzoBDC)2(dabco)

Caveat: Linker geometry must avoid steric hindrance; bulk crystalline azobenzene can suppress photoisomerisation.

7 · 6. Photoswitchable Nanoporous Coating · Figure 6

Direct SURMOF growth on QCM electrodes

SURMOFs are grown on the Au electrode of a quartz crystal microbalance so mass uptake and film growth can be monitored directly.

Claimed effects: Enables quantitative uptake, diffusion coefficient and activation-energy analysis for slow diffusion in thin porous films.

Controlling variables: QCM substrate · film thickness · guest atmosphere or liquid phase · temperature

Representative materials: Cu2(ndc)2(dabco) SURMOF · HKUST-1 SURMOF

Caveat: QCM uptake interpretation still requires distinguishing internal diffusion from surface barriers.

5 · 5. Unique Model System for Diffusion Experiments · Figure 4

Ultrasonication during LbL synthesis

A dipping robot combined with an ultrasonic bath improves rinsing of the film surface during synthesis.

Claimed effects: Reduces roughness, improves morphological homogeneity and markedly increases optical transparency of HKUST-1 SURMOFs.

Controlling variables: rinsing intensity · ultrasonic bath use · dipping automation · surface cleaning

Representative materials: HKUST-1 SURMOF

Caveat: The review reports optical-quality improvement but does not provide a general recipe for all SURMOF chemistries.

3 · 3. MOF Thin Films with Very Low Defect Density · Figure 2b

Review claims

These are the review authors’ synthesis, not newly measured results.

Author InterpretationHigh supportCaveat

Self-assembled chromophore aggregates often lack precise structural definition, whereas SURMOF crystalline chromophore assemblies offer defined structures for photophysical analysis.

Evidence basis: review_reasoning

Caveat: The review frames this as an emerging field rather than a mature device technology.

10 · 8. SURMOFs as Model-Systems

Author InterpretationHigh supportStructure Property Link

Crystalline porous SURMOFs provide free volume and structural definition for azobenzene switching, addressing limitations of sterically hindered crystals and amorphous polymers.

Evidence basis: review_reasoning

Caveat: Successful switching requires suitable linker geometry and sufficient pore space.

7 · 6. Photoswitchable Nanoporous Coating

Author InterpretationMedium supportTransport Mechanism

Ferrocene-loaded HKUST-1 SURMOF conductivity is interpreted as consistent with incoherent tunnelling or charge hopping, with approximately linear resistivity-thickness dependence.

Evidence basis: single_reference

Caveat: The review summarises one cited study rather than a broad consensus.

4 · 4. Determining Electrical Conductivity · Figure 3

Consensus SummaryHigh supportStructure Property Link

The electrical conductivity of otherwise insulating HKUST-1 SURMOFs can be increased strongly by loading electroactive guests into the pores.

Evidence basis: multi_reference

Caveat: Mechanism depends on guest identity and cannot be inferred solely from conductivity enhancement.

4 · 4. Determining Electrical Conductivity · Figure 3

DescriptiveHigh supportStructure Property Link

In chromophore-based SURMOF heterojunctions, interface quality strongly influences triplet transfer and photon upconversion properties.

Evidence basis: single_reference

Caveat: The review cites a specific Pd-DCP/ADB SURMOF heterojunction example.

10 · 7. Transfer of Electronic Excitations · Figure 9

DescriptiveHigh supportTransport Mechanism

Fluorinated azobenzene SURMOFs can modulate proton conduction of pore guests by light-induced changes in MOF-guest hydrogen bonding.

Evidence basis: single_reference

Caveat: The review discusses guest molecules such as butanediol and triazole; this is not general intrinsic proton conduction of the framework.

8 · 6.3. Photoswitchable Proton Conduction · Figure 7

DescriptiveHigh supportApplication Relevance

A two-part azobenzene SURMOF can act as a light-controlled nanoporous container whose top layer gates guest release.

Evidence basis: single_reference

Caveat: Demonstrated with 1,4-butanediol uptake/release in the cited example.

8 · 6.1. Remote-Controlled Release · Figure 6a-b

Consensus SummaryHigh supportStructure Property Link

High-quality SURMOFs can show substantially lower defect densities than normal bulk samples, improving their suitability for optical applications and spectroscopy.

Evidence basis: multi_reference

Caveat: Defect identity and density remain material- and processing-dependent.

3 · 3. MOF Thin Films with Very Low Defect Density · Figure 2

Author InterpretationHigh supportMeasurement Interpretation

MOF powders are often poor platforms for optical and electrical characterisation because scattering and electrode-contact issues obscure reliable measurements.

Evidence basis: review_reasoning

Caveat: The claim is made in the context of SURMOF advantages; it does not imply all powder measurements are invalid.

4 · 4. Determining Electrical Conductivity

Author InterpretationHigh supportMeasurement Interpretation

Pristine HKUST-1 SURMOFs show quadratic cyclohexane uptake-time scaling with film thickness, which the review interprets as diffusion-limited uptake with negligible surface-barrier influence.

Evidence basis: single_reference

Caveat: Exposure to humid air or water can create surface defects and change this behaviour.

6 · 5.1. The Surface Barrier Phenomenon · Figure 5

Consensus SummaryHigh supportCaveat

Surface barriers at external crystal surfaces can dominate apparent mass transfer and make diffusion coefficients in MOF powders differ by orders of magnitude.

Evidence basis: multi_reference

Caveat: The review attributes barriers mostly to near-surface structural imperfections but acknowledges measurement-to-measurement variability.

5 · 5.1. The Surface Barrier Phenomenon · Figure 5

Author InterpretationHigh supportDefinition Scope

SURMOFs are presented as monolithic, ordered MOF thin films that make MOFs usable as model systems for quantitative studies of molecular interactions in porous media.

Evidence basis: multi_reference

Caveat: This is the review's synthetic and measurement framing, not a universal property of all MOF films.

1 · Abstract

Author InterpretationMedium supportTransport Mechanism

TCNQ-loaded HKUST-1 shows high conductivity that the review says cannot be reconciled with simple hopping or band transport; an extended hopping or molecular superexchange model fits the data.

Evidence basis: single_reference

Caveat: This is a mechanistic interpretation of the cited work; primary papers should be checked for model assumptions.

4 · 4. Determining Electrical Conductivity

Author InterpretationHigh supportMeasurement Interpretation

Thin SURMOFs overcome the long uptake times of large crystals for slow diffusion, making low diffusion coefficients experimentally accessible.

Evidence basis: review_reasoning

Caveat: Shorter diffusion lengths help only if film quality and surface barriers are controlled.

5 · 5. Unique Model System for Diffusion Experiments

DescriptiveHigh supportApplication Relevance

Photoswitchable azobenzene SURMOF membranes can dynamically and reversibly tune H2/CO2 separation by controlling the cis-azobenzene ratio with light.

Evidence basis: single_reference

Caveat: The reported membrane relies on a specific pillared-layer azobenzene framework and in situ illumination.

8 · 6.2. Dynamic Remote-Control · Figure 6c-e

DescriptiveHigh supportSynthesis Strategy

Rinsing optimisation by ultrasonication during LbL growth can strongly improve morphology and visible transparency of HKUST-1 SURMOFs.

Evidence basis: single_reference

Caveat: Demonstrated for HKUST-1 films in the cited work.

4 · 3. MOF Thin Films with Very Low Defect Density · Figure 2b

Author InterpretationMedium supportStructure Property Link

Water or humid-air exposure can slow uptake without changing bulk XRD, supporting the interpretation that near-surface defects generate mass-transfer barriers.

Evidence basis: multi_reference

Caveat: The mechanism is proposed from combined uptake and XRD evidence rather than directly imaged pore blocking.

6 · 5.1. The Surface Barrier Phenomenon · Figure 5b-c

Secondary benchmarks

Every row remains visibly secondary and links to a primary dossier only where the mapping is verified.

MaterialPropertyReported valueContext and qualityPrimary evidenceReview source
SecondaryCu2(DMTPDC)2(AzoBiPyB) SURMOFthermal cis-to-trans isomerisation activation energy1.09 eV +/- 0.09 eVIR vibrational spectroscopy after UV irradiation; dark thermal relaxation
Text · Exact Reported
No verified corpus mapping10 · 6.4. SURMOFs as Regular Model System · Figure 8
SecondaryFerrocene in Cu2(ndc)2(dabco) SURMOFdiffusion activation energyapproximately +90 kJ mol^-1 (0.93 eV)Temperature-dependent QCM uptake in SURMOF films
Text · Approximate
No verified corpus mapping5 · 5. Unique Model System for Diffusion Experiments
SecondaryFerrocene-loaded HKUST-1 SURMOFconductivity increase upon ferrocene loadingabout an order of magnitudeMercury-droplet tunnelling junction conductivity measurements
Text · Approximate
No verified corpus mapping4 · 4. Determining Electrical Conductivity · Figure 3
SecondaryHKUST-1 SURMOF on Siin-plane thermal expansion coefficient(11.7 +/- 3.7) x 10^-6 K^-1In situ heating X-ray diffractometry; parallel to substrate
Text · Exact Reported
No verified corpus mapping2 · 2. MOF Mechanical Properties
SecondaryHKUST-1 SURMOF on Siout-of-plane thermal expansion coefficient(-75 +/- 16) x 10^-6 K^-1In situ heating X-ray diffractometry; z-direction perpendicular to surface
Text · Exact Reported
No verified corpus mapping2 · 2. MOF Mechanical Properties
SecondaryHKUST-1 SURMOFmissing-linker defect densityas low as 3%-4%Combination of XPS and IRRAS with CO probing of Cu ions
Text · Range
No verified corpus mapping3 · 3. MOF Thin Films with Very Low Defect Density
SecondaryHKUST-1 SURMOFYoung's modulus9.3 GPaStandard indentation on HKUST-1 SURMOF
Text · Exact Reported
No verified corpus mapping2 · 2. MOF Mechanical Properties
SecondaryCu2(AzoBPDC)2(AzoBiPyB) SURMOF membranecis-azobenzene ratio switching range0% to 63%UV or blue light irradiation; UV-vis and IR spectroscopy
Text · Range
No verified corpus mapping8 · 6.2. Dynamic Remote-Control · Figure 6e
SecondaryCu2(AzoBPDC)2(AzoBiPyB) SURMOF membraneH2/CO2 selection factor switching rangebetween 3 and 8Wicke-Kallenbach H2:CO2 separation under UV and blue light
Text · Range
No verified corpus mapping8 · 6.2. Dynamic Remote-Control · Figure 6d-e
SecondaryCu2(BPDC)2(BiPy)/Cu2(AzoBPDC)2(BiPy) SURMOFuptake rate-constant decrease on trans-to-cis switchingfactor of 15QCM uptake of 1,4-butanediol probe molecule
Text · Exact Reported
No verified corpus mapping8 · 6.1. Remote-Controlled Release · Figure 6b
SecondaryMOF crystal versus SURMOF filmuptake time comparison for D = 10^-18 m2 s^-1more than a year for 50 um crystal; one hour for 100 nm filmIllustrative diffusion-length comparison for slow guest uptake
Text · Approximate
No verified corpus mapping5 · 5. Unique Model System for Diffusion Experiments
SecondaryMOFsstructurally characterised examples by early 2017more than 70,000Literature count after about 20 years of MOF research
Text · Approximate
No verified corpus mapping1 · Introduction
SecondaryTCNQ-loaded HKUST-1 SURMOFconductivity increase upon guest loadingsix orders of magnitudeTCNQ loaded into pores of originally insulating HKUST-1 SURMOF
Text · Rounded Reported
research_00884 · 4. Determining Electrical Conductivity
SecondaryUHM-3 SURMOFCu+ concentrationbelow 1%Pristine sample; XPS with IRRAS corroboration
Text · Approximate
No verified corpus mapping3 · 3. MOF Thin Films with Very Low Defect Density · Figure 2a

Research gaps

Open questions are presented as review-author priorities, not conclusions from the primary database.

Chromophore aggregate structure

Medium

The precise structures of self-assembled chromophore aggregates are often unknown, hindering mechanistic understanding of chromophore-chromophore coupling.

Proposed direction: Use crystalline chromophore assembly SURMOFs and heteromultilayers with defined packing and optical quality.

10 · 8. SURMOFs as Model-Systems

Defect-transport coupling

Medium

The review shows that defects affect optical transparency, surface barriers and conduction contexts, but cross-property defect-transport correlations remain system-specific.

Proposed direction: Pair quantitative defect spectroscopy with conductivity, diffusion and optical measurements on the same controlled film series.

1 · Abstract

Electrical measurement reliability

High

Particulate MOF materials make it challenging to form reproducible, well-defined electrode contacts for conductivity analysis.

Proposed direction: Use oriented thin films and defined electrode geometries to separate intrinsic film transport from contact artefacts.

4 · 4. Determining Electrical Conductivity

Predictive photoswitchable materials

Medium

Amorphous photoswitchable materials lack structural definition, limiting quantitative comparison between molecular changes and macroscopic material response.

Proposed direction: Use crystalline porous SURMOFs with defined switch spacing and free volume for model-system comparisons with theory.

6 · 6. Photoswitchable Nanoporous Coating

Low-diffusivity guest measurement

High

Conventional diffusion tools are often unsuitable for low diffusion coefficients of large guests, especially below about 10^-12 m2 s^-1.

Proposed direction: Use thin SURMOF films and QCM or optical measurements to reduce diffusion length and measure slow uptake.

4 · 5. Unique Model System for Diffusion Experiments

Surface barriers and reproducibility

High

Surface barriers vary between measurements and batches, causing reported diffusion coefficients for identical powder materials to differ by orders of magnitude.

Proposed direction: Measure pristine films with controlled environmental exposure and separate surface resistance from intrinsic diffusion.

5 · 5.1. The Surface Barrier Phenomenon

Charge transport mechanism assignment

Medium

High conductivity in guest-loaded MOFs may not fit conventional hopping or band models, requiring more detailed theoretical and experimental discrimination.

Proposed direction: Combine thickness-dependent device data with electronic-structure modelling and guest-specific transport models.

4 · 4. Determining Electrical Conductivity

Photostimulation conditions

Medium

Some photoswitchable MOF functions rely on UV light, which can be undesirable for practical or biological applications.

Proposed direction: Use fluorinated azobenzene moieties or other visible-light switches to avoid UV activation.

8 · 6.2. Dynamic Remote-Control

Cited-study map

Mappings show which printed review references have a verified counterpart in the frozen primary corpus.

Show 30 cited-study records
ReferenceStudyRole and contextCorpus mapping
Ref. 32017Title unavailablescope_benchmarkCited for the reported count of structurally characterised MOFs by early 2017.Unmapped
Ref. 62016Title unavailableexciton_transfer · heterojunctionPrimary example for Dexter triplet transfer and photon upconversion across a SURMOF-SURMOF heterojunction.Unmapped
Ref. 92015Title unavailablesynthesis_quality · optical_qualityCited for ultrasonication-assisted LbL synthesis improving SURMOF roughness, homogeneity and transparency.Unmapped
Ref. 122016Title unavailablemechanical_benchmark · thermal_expansion · surmof_orientationCited for oriented HKUST-1 SURMOF diffraction, mechanical properties and anisotropic thermal expansion benchmarks.Unmapped
Ref. 132012Title unavailabledefect_benchmark · spectroscopyCited for CO-probe spectroscopy and XPS/IRRAS evidence that missing-linker defects in HKUST-1 SURMOFs can be low.Unmapped
Ref. 142015Title unavailabledefect_benchmark · annealingCited for XPS and IRRAS monitoring of Cu+ defect concentration in UHM-3 SURMOFs during annealing.Unmapped
Ref. 152017Title unavailabledefects · optical_absorptionCited for correlating visible absorption in regular films to Cu paddle-wheel defects where Cu++ is reduced to Cu+.research_0608
Ref. 172018Title unavailabledefect_control · modulationCited as evidence that SURMOF defect density can be controlled using water as a growth modulator.Unmapped
Ref. 182018Title unavailabledefect_control · synthesis_parametersCited for optimised synthesis parameters as another route to control SURMOF defect density.Unmapped
Ref. 202012Title unavailableguest_conductivityCited as early work showing guest-driven conductivity changes in HKUST-1 SURMOFs.Unmapped
Ref. 212014Title unavailableguest_conductivity · tcnqCited for strong conductivity enhancement of HKUST-1 after TCNQ loading.research_0088
Ref. 222015Title unavailableconductivity_measurement · ferroceneCited for mercury-droplet junction measurements of HKUST-1 SURMOF conductivity before and after ferrocene loading.Unmapped
Ref. 232016Title unavailabletransport_mechanism · superexchangeCited for detailed transport modelling of high conductivity in TCNQ-loaded HKUST-1, including molecular superexchange.research_0492
Ref. 272012Diffusion in Nanoporous Materialsdiffusion_contextCited for diffusion-length/time context used to motivate thin SURMOFs for slow diffusion measurements.Unmapped
Ref. 282017Title unavailableqcm_method · diffusionCited for QCM-based monitoring of guest uptake and mass transfer in SURMOFs.Unmapped
Ref. 302013Title unavailablediffusion_benchmark · activation_energyCited for QCM-derived ferrocene diffusion activation energy in Cu2(ndc)2(dabco) SURMOF films.Unmapped
Ref. 332011Title unavailablesurface_barriers · large_crystalsCited for experiments in large MOF crystals showing additional mass-transfer resistance at external surfaces.Unmapped
Ref. 342016Title unavailablesurface_barriers · zeolitesCited for surface barriers in zeolites and variability between measurements and batches.Unmapped
Ref. 352011Title unavailablesurface_barriers · near_surface_defectsCited for the interpretation that surface barriers likely arise from near-surface structural imperfections.Unmapped
Ref. 382014Title unavailablesurface_barrier_benchmark · qcm_diffusionCited for thickness-dependent QCM cyclohexane uptake experiments in HKUST-1 SURMOFs and water-induced surface barriers.Unmapped
Ref. 392019Title unavailablesurface_defect_repairCited for dissolving surface defects at elevated temperature in ethanol, restoring fast uptake and release.Unmapped
Ref. 472012Title unavailablephotoswitch_linkersCited for incorporating azobenzene units into crystalline nanoporous MOF structures.Unmapped
Ref. 482015Title unavailableazobenzene_switching · linker_designCited for adjusting linker length so trans-cis azobenzene switching is not sterically hindered.Unmapped
Ref. 502014Title unavailableremote_release · photoswitchable_surmoFCited for a two-part SURMOF molecular container with an azobenzene top layer acting as a light-controlled valve.Unmapped
Ref. 532016Title unavailablephotoswitchable_membrane · selectivity_benchmarkCited for light-tunable SURMOF membrane separation of H2/CO2 mixtures and continuous selectivity tuning.Unmapped
Ref. 562018Title unavailableproton_conduction · photoswitchable_surmoFCited for visible-light-switchable proton conduction of guest molecules in fluorinated azobenzene SURMOFs.Unmapped
Ref. 632015Title unavailableazobenzene_isomerisation · activation_energyCited for IR measurements and Arrhenius analysis of isolated azobenzene cis-to-trans thermal relaxation in SURMOFs.Unmapped
Ref. 652011Title unavailablechromophore_aggregatesCited for H- and J-aggregate photophysics as context for crystalline chromophore assemblies in SURMOFs.Unmapped
Ref. 662017Title unavailablecrystalline_chromophore_assemblyCited for the first example of crystalline H-aggregate SURMOFs with monitored emission-property changes.Unmapped
Ref. 672018Title unavailableanisotropic_exciton_transport · chromophore_assemblyCited for highly anisotropic crystalline chromophore assemblies with directional exciton diffusion in SURMOF heteromultilayers.Unmapped