Application RelevanceSupport assessment: Medium
The authors claim DIPRO@PTB transfers favourably to large, electronically complex MOC systems, giving good agreement with hybrid-DFT at substantially lower computational cost.
Caveat: The test system is a discrete Pd-linked metal-organic cage, not a measured conductive MOF, and the authors caution that the global PTB scaling factor may not suit extremely large or small systems.
PDF p9 / article p.144106-8 · VI. Conclusion and Outlook · Linked to 5 structured results
CaveatSupport assessment: High
The paper does not report a first-hand conductive MOF synthesis or experimental transport measurement; its MOF relevance is computational screening of coupling integrals and a MOC model.
Caveat: The main text discusses MOFs and includes a Pd-linked MOC, but no extended conductive MOF sample is synthesised or measured.
PDF p8 / article p.144106-7 · V.C. Challenging systems
CaveatSupport assessment: High
The PTB empirical scaling factor is size- and distance-dependent; homologous rows tend towards larger factors and distance increases can raise the factor substantially.
Caveat: This is a computational scaling limitation, not an experimental transport result.
SI p4-S5 · Dependencies of the Scaling Factor · Figure S2; Tables S1-S3 · Linked to 3 structured results
OtherSupport assessment: High
For the JAB69 benchmark, PBE-D4 performs best and PTB is second among the reported methods.
Caveat: Several molecules are excluded for some methods due to convergence issues or missing parameters.
PDF p6 / article p.144106-5 · V.B. JAB69 · Table II · Linked to 3 structured results
Structure Property LinkSupport assessment: Medium
PTB is described as the most robust tested method for HAB79 electronic couplings because it has few outliers and relatively meaningful structural-outlier behaviour.
Caveat: Robustness is computational and benchmark-specific; PTB scaling has known size, distance, and elemental-composition limitations.
PDF p6 / article p.144106-5 · V.A. HAB79 · Linked to 3 structured results