Primary studyCore evidenceTransport Physics

Ultrathin metal-organic framework array for efficient electrocatalytic water splitting

Duan J., Chen S., Zhao C. · Nature Communications · 2017 · 15341

10materials
14samples
8synthesis routes
20measurements
78results
9claims and caveats

Evidence map

Open a family to keep every result attached to its sample, method and conditions.

Author interpretations and caveats

Paraphrased for this database from the authors’ stated interpretations — never quoted verbatim — and kept separate from reported measurements.

Application RelevanceSupport assessment: Medium

The aqueous deposition strategy is presented as generic, extending to stainless steel mesh substrates and Cu-MOF nanosheets on nickel foam.

Caveat: Generality is demonstrated by morphology/AFM examples, not by transport/electrocatalysis for every additional material.

6 · Discussion · Linked to 3 structured results

Application RelevanceSupport assessment: High

The same NiFe-MOF electrode is bifunctional, showing the lowest HER overpotential and highest HER TOF among the paper’s Ni-MOF, bulk and calcined controls.

Caveat: HER values are application metrics; no standalone electronic transport during HER is measured.

3 · Electrocatalytic oxygen and hydrogen evolution · Linked to 5 structured results

Application RelevanceSupport assessment: High

NiFe-MOF/NF is the best first-hand OER sample in this paper by overpotential, Tafel slope, TOF and stability among the reported controls.

Caveat: Comparison is within the authors’ reported conditions without iR correction.

3 · Electrocatalytic oxygen and hydrogen evolution · Linked to 6 structured results

Application RelevanceSupport assessment: High

A two-electrode cell using NiFe-MOF as both anode and cathode reaches 10 mA cm-2 at 1.55 V and remains stable for 20 h, outperforming the paper’s Pt/C + IrO2 benchmark cell under the stated comparison.

Caveat: Benchmark cell voltage is calculated from the reported 70 mV difference.

3 · Electrocatalytic overall water splitting · Linked to 5 structured results

Structure Property LinkSupport assessment: High

Direct growth of NiFe-MOF on nickel foam avoids insulating binder and lowers electrode internal resistance compared with Nafion-assisted bulk NiFe-MOF/NF, improving electron transport.

Caveat: Internal resistance comes from EIS in electrolyte rather than dry intrinsic conductivity.

5 · Discussion · Linked to 2 structured results

Structure Property LinkSupport assessment: High

The NiFe-MOF/NF electrode combines nickel-foam macropores, tens-of-nanometre open pores between vertical nanosheets, mesopores and intrinsic microporosity, supporting electrolyte/product mass transport during water splitting.

Caveat: Mass-transport role is inferred from structural characterisation and electrocatalytic performance; no direct diffusion coefficient is reported.

5 · Discussion · Linked to 4 structured results

Structure Property LinkSupport assessment: High

Ultrathin NiFe-MOF nanosheets expose molecular Ni/Fe metal sites to electrolyte, giving a larger double-layer capacitance and better catalytic performance than bulk or calcined controls.

Caveat: Cdl is an electrochemical surface-area proxy, not a direct active-site count.

5 · Discussion · Linked to 6 structured results

Synthesis MechanismSupport assessment: Medium

The nanosheet array forms by a dissolution-crystallisation mechanism, evolving from microrods at 3 h to small nanosheets at 10 h and large nanosheets at 20 h.

Caveat: Mechanism is inferred from time-dependent morphology rather than in situ tracking.

2 · Results · Supplementary Fig. 4 · Linked to 3 structured results

Transport MechanismSupport assessment: Medium

2D nanostructuration gives NiFe-MOF nanosheets intrinsic conductivity about three orders of magnitude higher than the bulk counterpart, attributed by the authors to vacancy engineering and increased carrier concentration in metal octahedral units.

Caveat: Mechanistic vacancy/carrier explanation is interpretive; conductivity values are directly reported but only as pressed-film/pellet measurements.

5 · Discussion · Linked to 2 structured results

Material identities

Names and aliases are kept exactly within the paper’s own identity model.

MaterialCompositionStructure contextSource
Bulk NiFe-MOF powderNiFe-MOF composition not separately refined; related to NiFe-MOFMixed Ni/Fe MOF nodes. · 2,6-naphthalenedicarboxylate.2D · PristineBulk counterpart made of aggregated nanosheets and lacking the hierarchical nanosheet-array morphology.S4 · Supplementary Figure 2 · Supplementary Fig. 2
Calcined NiFe-MOF derived controlCalcined NiFe-MOF-derived material; exact phase not reportedNi/Fe-derived inorganic sites after calcination. · Molecular NiFe MOF sites removed/altered by calcination.unknown · DerivedCalcined control at 650 deg C in N2, described as without molecular NiFe sites.3 · Electrocatalytic oxygen and hydrogen evolution
Cu-MOF ultrathin nanosheet arrayNot reported; Cu-based naphthalenedicarboxylate MOFCu MO6 units by analogy to the stated M = Ni, Fe or Cu framework. · 2,6-naphthalenedicarboxylate.2D · PristineCopper-based MOF nanosheets grown on nickel foam; SEM, EDS and AFM shown.6 · Discussion · Supplementary Fig. 28
Fe-MOF/NF controlNot reported; iron-only naphthalenedicarboxylate MOF controlFe-containing MOF nodes, Ni omitted. · 2,6-naphthalenedicarboxylate.2D · PristineFe-only MOF control reported for OER comparison.3 · Electrocatalytic oxygen and hydrogen evolution
Iridium(IV) oxide benchmark catalystIrO2Ir oxide. · None.unknown · UnknownCommercial benchmark OER catalyst.S1 · Supplementary Methods; Chemicals
Organic-ligand-only nickel foam control2,6-naphthalenedicarboxylic acid dipotassium on nickel foam controlNo added metal salt; nickel foam substrate present. · 2,6-naphthalenedicarboxylic acid dipotassium.0D · Model SystemControl showing no ligand deposition under the synthetic condition.S3 · Supplementary Figure 1 · Supplementary Fig. 1
Ni-MOF array controlNi(C12H6O4)(H2O)4-like nickel naphthalenedicarboxylate hydrateNi octahedral MO6 units. · 2,6-naphthalenedicarboxylate.2D · PristineNickel-only MOF control, described as without Fe; XRD comparison close to Ni(C12H6O4)(H2O)4.3 · Electrocatalytic oxygen and hydrogen evolution
Nickel foam substrate/controlNiMetallic nickel substrate. · None.unknown · UnknownMacroporous nickel foam substrate, also tested as a no-MOF control.S1 · Supplementary Methods; Chemicals
NiFe-MOF ultrathin 2D metal-organic frameworkMain text: Ni0.8Fe0.2(C12H6O4)(H2O)4; SI EDS/ICP variants: Ni0.86Fe0.14(C12H6O4)(H2O)4 and Ni0.83Fe0.17(C12H6O4)(H2O)4Mixed Ni/Fe octahedral MO6 units; Ni2+ and Fe3+ indicated by XPS. · 2,6-naphthalenedicarboxylate / 2,6-naphthalenedicarboxylic acid dipotassium.2D · PristineAlternating organic hydrocarbon layers and inorganic metal-oxygen layers; each metal ion coordinated to two trans monodentate carboxylates and four water molecules.2 · Results; Characterizations of the NiFe-MOF electrode · Figure 1; Figure 2
Pt/C cathode plus IrO2 anode benchmark cellPt/C + IrO2Pt and Ir oxide benchmark electrocatalysts. · None.unknown · CompositeBenchmark full-water-splitting electrode pair.5 · Electrocatalytic overall water splitting · Figure 4c

Sample register

Sample form, processing state and composition status define the context for measurements.

Show 14 sample records
SampleForm and roleProcessing and geometrySource
Bulk NiFe-MOF powder drop-cast on nickel foamresearch_0071__mat__mat_bulk_nife_mofElectrode · Pristine Control · CompositeNiFe-MOF powder dispersed in isopropanol/water with 1 wt% Nafion and drop-cast at 0.3 mg cm-2 loading.Nickel foamS1 · Supplementary Methods · Synthesis of bulk NiFe-MOF/NF
Cu-MOF/NF nanosheet sampleresearch_0071__mat__mat_cu_mofElectrode · Target Sample · Pristine FrameworkPrepared similarly to NiFe-MOF/NF except Cu(Ac)2 was used as metal precursor.Nickel foam · AFM thickness ca. 6.8 nmS30 · Supplementary Figure 28 · Supplementary Fig. 28
Fe-MOF/NF controlresearch_0071__mat__mat_fe_mofElectrode · Pristine Control · Pristine FrameworkPrepared as Fe-only MOF control; exact recipe not stated.Nickel foam3 · Electrocatalytic oxygen and hydrogen evolution
IrO2 benchmark electroderesearch_0071__mat__mat_iro2Electrode · Pristine Control · UnknownCommercial IrO2 benchmark, 0.3 mg cm-2 loading in SI Table 1.Electrode substrate not fully specified for OER benchmarkS31 · Supplementary Table 1 · Supplementary Table 1
Organic-ligand-only nickel foam controlresearch_0071__mat__mat_ligand_controlElectrode · Pristine Control · ModelSynthetic condition with only organic ligand and no added metal salts.Nickel foamS3 · Supplementary Figure 1 · Supplementary Fig. 1
Ni-MOF/NF array controlresearch_0071__mat__mat_ni_mofElectrode · Pristine Control · Pristine FrameworkPrepared analogously to NiFe-MOF but without Fe; exact precursor amount not stated.Nickel foam3 · Electrocatalytic oxygen and hydrogen evolution
Bare nickel foam controlresearch_0071__mat__mat_nickel_foamElectrode · Pristine Control · UnknownNo MOF deposited; used as substrate/control.Nickel foam · 1.6 mm3 · Electrocatalytic oxygen and hydrogen evolution
Calcined NiFe-MOF controlresearch_0071__mat__mat_calcined_nife_mofElectrode · Pristine Control · Derived CarbonCalcined at 650 deg C for 6 h in N2 with 5 deg C min-1 ramp.Derived from NiFe-MOF electrodeS1 · Supplementary Methods · Calcination of NiFe-MOF
NiFe-MOF/GC macrodisc electroderesearch_0071__mat__mat_nife_mofElectrode · Pristine Control · CompositeNiFe-MOF drop-cast on glassy carbon at 0.3 mg cm-2 loading.Glassy carbon macrodiscS12 · Supplementary Figure 10 · Supplementary Fig. 10
NiFe-MOF/NF ultrathin nanosheet array electroderesearch_0071__mat__mat_nife_mofElectrode · Target Sample · Mixed MetalDirectly grown in situ by aqueous chemical bath deposition; rinsed after 1 min bath ultrasonication.Nickel foam (2 cm x 1 cm x 1.6 mm in synthesis; macroporous NF support) · AFM nanolayer thickness ca. 3.5 nm; nickel foam thickness 1.6 mm2 · Results; Characterizations of the NiFe-MOF electrode · Figure 2
Pressed NiFe-MOF nanosheet thin film for four-point-probe conductivityresearch_0071__mat__mat_nife_mofThin Film · Target Sample · Mixed Metal2D MOF nanosheets scratched from nickel foam and pressed at 10 MPa for 3 min.Pressed pellet/thin film from nanosheets scratched from nickel foam · ca. 240 nm by Supplementary Fig. 25; Methods also state circular pellet 43 um thick for conductivity measurement5 · Discussion · Supplementary Fig. 25
NiFe-MOF on stainless steel meshresearch_0071__mat__mat_nife_mofElectrode · Target Sample · Mixed MetalPrepared similarly to NiFe-MOF/NF except stainless steel mesh was used as support.Stainless steel mesh · few nanometres; lateral size several micrometresS29 · Supplementary Figure 27 · Supplementary Fig. 27
Pt/C cathode plus IrO2 anode benchmark full cellresearch_0071__mat__mat_ptc_iro2_benchmarkElectrode · Pristine Control · CompositePt/C cathode and IrO2 anode used as benchmark for full water splitting.Two-electrode benchmark cell5 · Figure 4 caption · Figure 4c
Two-electrode cell using two NiFe-MOF electrodesresearch_0071__mat__mat_nife_mofElectrode · Target Sample · Mixed MetalTwo-electrode water-splitting configuration using NiFe-MOF as both anode and cathode.Two NiFe-MOF electrodes on nickel foam used as anode and cathode3 · Electrocatalytic overall water splitting · Figure 4c