Primary studyCore evidenceTransport Physics

Synthesis of ordered carbonaceous frameworks from organic crystals

Nishihara H., Hirota T., Matsuura K. et al. · Nature Communications · 2017 · 109

7materials
12samples
8synthesis routes
13measurements
72results
7claims and caveats

Evidence map

Open a family to keep every result attached to its sample, method and conditions.

Author interpretations and caveats

Paraphrased for this database from the authors’ stated interpretations — never quoted verbatim — and kept separate from reported measurements.

Application RelevanceSupport assessment: High

Selective CO2-to-CO electrocatalysis in Ni2-CPDPy973(1) is attributed to Ni-N4 sites embedded in a conductive carbonaceous framework.

Caveat: Partial current densities are estimated from the plotted figure; FE values are text-reported.

7 · Electrochemical catalysis · Fig. 6 · Linked to 5 structured results

CaveatSupport assessment: High

The target conductive materials are derived carbonaceous frameworks from an organic molecular crystal, not first-hand conductive MOFs.

Caveat: The introduction discusses MOF-derived carbons in the broader literature, but the reported precursor is a cyclic porphyrin dimer organic crystal.

1 · Abstract · Linked to 3 structured results

CaveatSupport assessment: High

The present OCFs are poorly porous; BET surface area decreases from 48 to 14 m2 g-1 when carbonisation temperature increases from 873 to 973 K.

Caveat: CO2 pore volume for Ni2-CPDPy973(1) was not measured.

24 · Supplementary Table 2 · Supplementary Table 2 · Linked to 4 structured results

Phase AssignmentSupport assessment: High

The Ni-N4 coordination environment is largely retained in the carbonised OCFs.

Caveat: Ni2-CPDPy973(1) also shows evidence for a small metallic Ni contribution.

6 · Chemical environment of Ni in the carbon matrix · Fig. 5 · Linked to 4 structured results

Structure Property LinkSupport assessment: High

Ni in the porphyrin centre stabilises the precursor against thermochemical decomposition, improving carbon yield and retention of ordered structure relative to H4-CPDPy.

Caveat: Comparison is between Ni-containing and free-base porphyrin dimers; other metals were not experimentally extracted here.

2 · Carbonization of Ni2-CPDPy · Fig. 1 · Linked to 4 structured results

Synthesis MechanismSupport assessment: High

Ni2-CPDPy crystals thermally convert first into a crystalline covalent-organic framework intermediate and then into ordered carbonaceous frameworks.

Caveat: Starting precursor synthesis details are external to this paper.

7 · Discussion · Linked to 3 structured results

Transport MechanismSupport assessment: High

Carbonisation generates electrically conductive OCFs; Ni2-CPDPy873(1) and Ni2-CPDPy973(1) show semiconducting resistivity behaviour.

Caveat: Transport samples included PTFE binder for carbonised samples; Ni2-CPDPy973(1) used four-probe geometry while 873 K sample used two-electrode method.

6 · Chemical structure transition upon carbonization · Supplementary Fig. 13 · Linked to 4 structured results

Material identities

Names and aliases are kept exactly within the paper’s own identity model.

MaterialCompositionStructure contextSource
H4-CPDPy free-base porphyrin dimer controlNot specifiedNone; free-base porphyrin · Free-base cyclic porphyrin dimer with diacetylene moietiesunknown · PristineLow-crystallinity free-base control; broad PXRD peaks and poor ordered-structure retention after pyrolysis.9 · Supplementary Figure 7 caption · Supplementary Fig. 7
Ni2-CPDPy guest-free cyclic porphyrin dimer crystalC92H48N12Ni2Two square-planar Ni-N4 porphyrin centres per cyclic dimer · Cyclic porphyrin dimer with butadiyne (diacetylene), phenyl, and meso-pyridyl groups3D · PristineGuest-free molecular crystal; monoclinic P21/c from PXRD/Rietveld refinement; columnar packing with diacetylene moieties aligned for solid-state polymerisation.2-4 · Results; Crystallographic structural changes upon carbonization · Fig. 2; Supplementary Fig. 2
Ni2-CPDPy593(0) crystalline covalent-organic framework intermediateC92H48N12Ni2Retained square-planar Ni-N4 porphyrin centres · Poly(diacetylene) backbone cross-linking CPDPy units2D · PristineCrystalline polymer/COF intermediate; stacked two-dimensional sheets after thermal polymerisation at 593 K.4 · Crystallographic structural changes upon carbonization · Fig. 2h-j; Supplementary Fig. 4-5
Ni2-CPDPy873(1) ordered carbonaceous frameworkC/N/Ni/H/O carbonaceous framework derived from Ni2-CPDPyMostly retained Ni-N4 units embedded in carbonaceous matrix · Carbonaceous framework from porphyrin, phenyl, pyridyl, and polydiacetylene moieties3D · DerivedOrdered carbonaceous framework retaining periodicity from the precursor polymer; defective graphene-like sheets with embedded Ni-N4 sites.4-6 · Crystallographic structural changes; Chemical environment of Ni · Fig. 2m; Fig. 5
Ni2-CPDPy973(1) ordered carbonaceous frameworkC/N/Ni/H/O carbonaceous framework derived from Ni2-CPDPyPredominantly retained Ni-N4 units with minor metallic Ni contribution · Carbonaceous framework from Ni2-CPDPy-derived aromatic and polydiacetylene fragments3D · DerivedHigher-temperature OCF retaining structural regularity with small shrinkage; conductive and catalytically active for CO2-to-CO.4,7 · Crystallographic structural changes; Electrochemical catalysis · Fig. 2g; Fig. 6
Ni-TPP973(1) conventional Ni/N/C referenceNi/N/CDisordered Ni species and Ni metal aggregates · Carbonised nickel tetraphenylporphyrin-derived carbonaceous matrixunknown · CompositeDisordered Ni/N/C composite from carbonised Ni-TPP; Ni-N bonds cleaved and Ni metal formed.21 · Supplementary Figure 18 caption · Supplementary Fig. 18
Zeolite-templated carbon referenceCNone · sp2 carbon framework3D · DerivedReference ordered microporous carbon with 13.8 Angstrom periodicity.7 · Electrochemical catalysis · Fig. 6d

Sample register

Sample form, processing state and composition status define the context for measurements.

Show 12 sample records
SampleForm and roleProcessing and geometrySource
H4-CPDPyresearch_0458__mat__mat_h4_cpdpyPowder · Pristine Control · Pristine FrameworkFree-base organic control before heat treatment.2 · Carbonization of Ni2-CPDPy · Fig. 1b,d
H4-CPDPy873(1)research_0458__mat__mat_h4_cpdpyPowder · Pristine Control · Derived CarbonFree-base control heated to 873 K for 1 h.9 · Supplementary Figure 7 caption · Supplementary Fig. 7
Ni2-CPDPyresearch_0458__mat__mat_ni2_cpdpyPowder · Target Sample · Pristine FrameworkGuest-free organic crystal precursor; uncarbonised.4 · Crystallographic structural changes upon carbonization · Fig. 2a
Ni2-CPDPy593(0)research_0458__mat__mat_ni2_cpdpy593Powder · Target Sample · Pristine FrameworkHeated to 593 K and stopped immediately; polymerised COF intermediate.3 · Fig. 2 caption · Fig. 2b
Ni2-CPDPy873(1)research_0458__mat__mat_ni2_cpdpy873_ocfPowder · Target Sample · Derived CarbonCarbonised at 873 K for 1 h under N2 flow.3 · Fig. 2 caption · Fig. 2c,m
Ni2-CPDPy973(1)research_0458__mat__mat_ni2_cpdpy973_ocfPowder · Target Sample · Derived CarbonCarbonised at 973 K for 1 h under N2 flow.4,7 · Crystallographic structural changes; Electrochemical catalysis · Fig. 2g; Fig. 6
Ni2-CPDPy973(1)/Nafion catalyst layerresearch_0458__mat__mat_ni2_cpdpy973_ocfElectrode · Composite Sample · CompositeCatalyst ink drop-cast from sample and Nafion solution.glassy carbon plate27 · Evaluation of selective CO2 reduction into CO · Supplementary Methods
Ni2-CPDPy/Nafion catalyst layerresearch_0458__mat__mat_ni2_cpdpyElectrode · Composite Sample · CompositePristine organic crystal mixed with Nafion and drop-cast.glassy carbon plate27 · Evaluation of selective CO2 reduction into CO · Supplementary Methods
Ni-TPP973(1)research_0458__mat__mat_nitpp973Powder · Pristine Control · CompositeNickel tetraphenylporphyrin carbonised at 973 K for 1 h.7 · Electrochemical catalysis · Fig. 6
Ni-TPP973(1)/Nafion catalyst layerresearch_0458__mat__mat_nitpp973Electrode · Composite Sample · CompositeConventional Ni/N/C control mixed with Nafion and drop-cast.glassy carbon plate27 · Evaluation of selective CO2 reduction into CO · Supplementary Methods
ZTCresearch_0458__mat__mat_ztcPowder · Pristine Control · Derived CarbonReference zeolite-templated ordered microporous carbon.7 · Electrochemical catalysis · Fig. 6d
ZTC/Nafion catalyst layerresearch_0458__mat__mat_ztcElectrode · Composite Sample · CompositeReference carbon catalyst layer with Nafion.glassy carbon plate27 · Evaluation of selective CO2 reduction into CO · Supplementary Methods