Application RelevanceSupport assessment: Medium
A graphitic-rod counter-electrode control preserves the same HER activity trend, with Ni-BTC retaining the lowest Tafel slope among the three metal-BTC electrodes.
Caveat: The supporting values are read from labels on SI Fig. S4b rather than prose or a table.
main p.5, article p.176 · Results and discussion · Fig. S4 · Linked to 3 structured results
Application RelevanceSupport assessment: High
Ni-BTC/CFP is the best-performing of the three metal-BTC HER electrodes, with the lowest overpotential, lowest Rct, largest Cdl/ECSA, highest mass activity and highest TOF.
Caveat: Performance is measured on composite MOF/CFP electrodes, not on an isolated pristine powder conductivity device.
main p.1, article p.172 · Abstract · Linked to 7 structured results
CaveatSupport assessment: High
The paper describes the MOFs as conductive/electrocatalytic but does not report a direct electrical conductivity, Seebeck coefficient, or thermoelectric measurement for the pristine powders.
Caveat: Electrochemical impedance Rct values are application measurements on MOF/CFP electrodes and should not be treated as intrinsic electrical transport conductivity.
main p.1, article p.172 · Abstract · Linked to 3 structured results
Phase AssignmentSupport assessment: Medium
Post-HER XRD and SEM suggest the metal-BTC/CFP electrodes retain their framework structure and morphology after reaction.
Caveat: Post-HER XRD and SEM evidence is qualitative in the extraction; no post-HER peak positions or morphology metrics were quantified.
main p.6, article p.177 · Results and discussion · Figs. S8-S9 · Linked to 3 structured results
Structure Property LinkSupport assessment: Medium
The authors attribute superior HER activity to high porosity, large specific surface area, tunable composition, diverse morphology with high crystallinity, rich metal centres and high durability.
Caveat: This is an interpretive structure-performance claim; direct causal isolation of each structural factor is not demonstrated.
main p.7, article p.178 · Conclusions · Linked to 4 structured results
Synthesis MechanismSupport assessment: Medium
The three metal centres were chosen to span the HER volcano plot, with Ni and Co on the left side and Cu on the right side of the volcano peak.
Caveat: The volcano-plot rationale is a design framing rather than a directly measured thermodynamic descriptor in this paper.
main p.2, article p.173 · Introduction · Linked to 3 structured results