CaveatSupport assessment: High
The authors caution that further experiments are required to improve crystalline quality and to unambiguously exclude magnetic secondary phases.
Caveat: This caveat is stated directly in the main article and echoed in peer review.
p007 · Discussion · Linked to 3 structured results
Phase AssignmentSupport assessment: Medium
The target material is assigned as a layered, AA-serrated K3Fe2[PcFe-O8] framework with square lattice geometry and 3.3 A interlayer spacing.
Caveat: Authors acknowledge that polycrystallinity and local HRTEM/PXRD do not fully exclude amorphous phases; no CIF was assigned in the prompt.
p002-p003 · Synthesis and structural analysis · Figure 1 · Linked to 5 structured results
Phase AssignmentSupport assessment: Medium
XANES/EXAFS and contrast samples were used to argue that FeO and Fe2O3 oxide impurities were not detected in K3Fe2[PcFe-O8].
Caveat: Detection is limited by analytical resolution; the authors do not claim absolute exclusion of all secondary phases.
p003 · Synthesis and structural analysis · Figure 1d-e · Linked to 2 structured results
Structure Property LinkSupport assessment: Medium
DFT assigns the AA-serrated stacked model as a narrow-gap semiconductor and predicts the ferromagnetic arrangement to be favoured by about 300 meV.
Caveat: DFT+U/PBE may underestimate band gaps; computational prediction supports but does not prove macroscopic ferromagnetism.
p004 · Electronic structure · Figure 2c-d · Linked to 3 structured results
Structure Property LinkSupport assessment: Medium
Counterions reduce accessible porosity: K3Fe2[PcFe-O8] has 206 m2/g BET area and ~1.4 nm pores, while the Li analogue reaches 343 m2/g and ~1.45 nm pores.
Caveat: The Li analogue synthesis is only described as same method and no transport data are reported for it.
p014 · Supplementary Figure 7 · Supplementary Figure 7 · Linked to 4 structured results
Structure Property LinkSupport assessment: Medium
The magnetic response is interpreted as blocked superparamagnetism from nanoscale crystallites with ferromagnetic coupling within individual K3Fe2[PcFe-O8] crystallites.
Caveat: The main text explicitly says further experiments are needed to unambiguously exclude magnetic secondary phases; reviewer 2 raised concerns about ferromagnetism vs spin-glass/superparamagnetic scenarios.
p006-p007 · Discussion · Figure 4 · Linked to 5 structured results
Transport MechanismSupport assessment: Medium
The Fe redox state contributes to conductivity because air oxidation increases Fe3+ content and lowers conductivity by 2-3 orders of magnitude.
Caveat: Oxidation experiment is a contrast study; it does not isolate all structural or hydration changes.
p029 · Supplementary Figure 21 · Supplementary Figure 21 · Linked to 3 structured results
Transport MechanismSupport assessment: High
K3Fe2[PcFe-O8] behaves as a p-type semiconductor: temperature-dependent conductivity increases non-linearly with temperature, Hall resistance has a positive p-type slope, and TRTS gives high room-temperature mobility.
Caveat: Bulk pellet DC transport is limited by grain boundaries and contact resistance; TRTS mobility is photoinduced/contact-free.
p004-p005 · Charge transport and magnetotransport · Figure 3 · Linked to 6 structured results