CaveatSupport assessment: High
Conventional solution and de novo trials did not form Mn-HOF-MA or Mn-HOF-FA, supporting the requirement for mechanochemical grinding.
Caveat: Control experiments were screened by IR/PXRD rather than isolated-product analysis.
p005 · Control experiments · Figures S10-S12
CaveatSupport assessment: High
After EIS at elevated temperature and humidity, IR spectra and water sorption remain essentially unchanged, and SEM-EDX indicates retained morphology and homogeneous elemental dispersion.
Caveat: PXRD showed transient new reflections after EIS at high RH, which practically disappeared after a water vapour adsorption-desorption cycle.
p005 · Proton conductive properties · Figures S33-S46 · Linked to 1 structured result
Synthesis MechanismSupport assessment: High
Solvent-free/liquid-assisted mechanochemistry converts non-conductive JUK-1 into proton-conducting Mn-HOF-MA and Mn-HOF-FA by breaking Mn-carboxylate coordination links and forming extended hydrogen-bonded networks.
Caveat: The JUK-1 and JUK-2 precursor recipes are cited from earlier literature and not fully reproduced in this SI.
p003 · Structural details of solid-state reactions · Fig. 2 · Linked to 4 structured results
Synthesis MechanismSupport assessment: High
The solid-state Mn-HOF formations are reversible: Mn-HOF-MA and Mn-HOF-FA return to JUK-1 after immersion in ethanol.
Caveat: Reversibility is evidenced by PXRD after ethanol treatment.
p003 · Postsynthetic modification and physicochemical characterization · Fig. S13
Transport MechanismSupport assessment: High
Relative humidity strongly increases proton conductivity, indicating that ions are the primary charge carriers.
Caveat: Mn-HOF-MA and JUK-2 were not measured at 75% RH because of deliquescence.
p004 · Proton conductive properties · Fig. 3, Table S6 · Linked to 5 structured results
Transport MechanismSupport assessment: Medium
Arrhenius activation energies are interpreted as mainly indicating a humidity-independent vehicle mechanism involving diffusion of formamidinium and methylammonium cations.
Caveat: The authors also infer possible pressure/temperature/humidity-induced MHOF phase transitions from two-slope Arrhenius behaviour.
p004 · Proton conductive properties · Fig. S31 · Linked to 3 structured results